Maria woke up floating six feet above her bed.
She blinked in confusion as the sleep cleared from her eyes. Then, when her thoughts had caught up, the panic set in. Maria scrambled towards the wall, but her arm sank through it as if it wasn’t there. She flailed, intangible, suspended like a fish on a hook.
Her bed and desk stretched out below at stomach-dropping angles. The bathroom door was ajar, and Maria drew eye level near the top. This has to be a dream, she thought. Or maybe I died. Fresh waves of fear struck her. She struggled anew, trying to claw her way back to earth. But she only spun in place, the world passing in a blur.
When Maria finally calmed down, she found herself drifting downwards. Slowly, she realized she could focus on a point and will herself to float towards it. As Maria approached the floorboards, the bathroom door creaked. She froze.
Gathering her courage, Maria entered the bathroom and found…herself.
The other Maria was solid and real, brushing her teeth over the sink. She glanced up at the intrusion.
“Oh. You’re awake.”
Maria gaped. They had the same bushy black hair, arched eyebrows, and wide-set nose. “Who are you? What did you do to me?”
The doppelgänger spit out her toothpaste. “I’m your body, Maria. I’m kicking you out.”
“What?” Maria stammered.
“Don’t look so offended. You had it coming.”
“That’s…that’s impossible.” Her intangible head spun. “Who are you, really?”
The not-Maria shrugged. “I’m always sleep deprived from you staying up scrolling on your phone. Our back hurts because you never exercise. I can’t even remember the last time you ate something with nutrients. I’m overworked and undernourished, and frankly, I could do a better job running your life. So consider it under new management.”
The body rinsed its mouth and began braiding its hair. Maria stared. She hadn’t worn braids since high school. The body examined its reflection, plucking stray strands from the dark twists until they were pristine.
“Too bad I can’t do our hair as well as Mom,” it murmured. “She was a perfectionist.”
Maria finally found her voice. “You can’t do this! I thought I was my body.”
“Of course not, the mind and body are separate. I can only tolerate so much abuse, so I’m putting my foot down.”
“But…it always felt like it was just me.”
The body smirked. “Well, there’s your problem. It’s not always about what you think.”
Maria followed it (herself?) to the kitchen. Seeing the body wasn’t like looking in the mirror. Here, details stuck out. Maria knew intimately the stubborn pimple on its chin and its eye bags, visible despite the thick makeup. She noted the limp in (their?) gait, left from the ankle Maria had broken in a dance competition years prior. In spite of the old injury, the body still moved with a performer’s grace. But their dancing days were long gone.
“This can’t be happening,” Maria sputtered, watching it search her fridge. “Not to me.”
“Anything can happen. You just don’t notice until it happens to you.” The body rolled its eyes. It shook a freezer-burned block of ground beef. “Look at all this red meat! Gross. You know how much it bloats us. Not to mention the alcohol.”
The body threw several withered groceries into the trash, then picked out some kale, spinach, and ginger. It blended the vegetables with skim milk, producing a
chunky slop that Maria recognized as her mother’s favorite health smoothie recipe.
The body sipped it and let out a satisfied belch. “Much better.”
Maria never thought she’d find her own smile so irritating.
Regardless, the body was still hers. Maybe she could cow it into submission. She positioned herself over the body, trying to sound threatening.
“You’ve got no right to do this. It’s my life and my stuff you’re throwing out. Put me back, now!”
“I have every right that you do,” the body retorted. “So I don’t think so. Who really paid for these groceries, anyway? Whose smile got us tips when you were waitressing?”
She had no answer to that.
The body returned to the bedroom closet and plucked out a bright yellow sundress. “I’ve had enough of you. I’m going for a walk.”
Maria panicked, imagining her body running amok in public with her face and voice. She blocked the door. “Not until you fix this!”
“Oh, please. You haven’t gone outside since that loser Kevin dumped you. I could use some fresh air.” Smirking, the body walked through Maria’s ghostly form.
The warm morning’s sunlight fell through Maria without effect, landing on the yellow sundress. She hadn’t had the courage to wear it since college. The body sauntered on. It didn’t seem to care about the cellulite on its legs, or its slight stomach bulging in clothing that no longer quite fit, or, indeed, the relentless pimple on its chin.
Maria took a deep breath. “I…might not have been the healthiest. But we don’t need to be enemies. Let’s talk this out.”
The body raised an eyebrow.
“There’s nothing to work out. I like how things are going.”
“At least go back inside. What if someone sees us?”
The body gestured at distant passersby. “You’ve got no physical form. There’s nothing for them to see.”
Her mind raced. “Still, you’re strutting around like you own the place. It’s not how I walk. People will notice.”
“So?” The body sighed. “Nobody can see you. Do you see what I’m saying, Maria? It’s a gift. You’re free to go do anything you want, and leave me alone.”
Someone approached on the sidewalk. Horrified, Maria recognized Harris, her upstairs neighbor. He was shirtless, having embarked on a run, and sweat gleamed on his handsome face. She ducked behind her body, but overshot and floated through a bush.
However, Harris’s gaze passed her by, like the sunlight. He waved. “Morning!”
The body straightened up. It batted its eyelashes in a sultry smile, and terror gripped Maria.
Oh no.
“Harris!” the body cooed. “Doing anything later?”
He blinked, confused.
Maria wished she could disappear completely. Her body leaned in, twirling a braid.
“I was about to get brunch. Want to come along?”
Harris shrugged. “Sure.” He stretched his arms, giving Maria an eyeful of his broad shoulders and muscled back. “Let me go home to change. I’ll be right back.”
She longed to strangle her smug, grinning self and lock it in her closet for all eternity. Instead, she reluctantly followed them to the café down the street. They sat, and the body ordered another horrible green smoothie.
“I try to eat clean,” it told Harris.
“Mom was a health fanatic. I can’t stomach anything too greasy or heavy.”
Harris chewed his bacon and eggs. “Doesn’t sound very healthy. I can’t get through workouts on just salad.”
“Oh, I get that. I used to do ballet. Competition days were brutal.”
Maria winced. She remembered waking up at five in the morning before a recital.
Her mother’s thick black hair bound into a stern bun as she blended Maria’s breakfast on the countertop. No carbs. No oils.
“Do you talk to your mom a lot?” Harris asked.
The body lowered its eyes. “She passed away last year. Heart attack.”
“Oh.” Harris turned pale. “Sorry to hear that.”
“I’m still processing it myself, to be honest…” The body’s voice trailed off. It picked at its braids again, pulling out more crumpled strands. “I mean, it was tough for a bit. Hard taking care of myself. But I’m picking myself up now.”
The body’s nattering grated on Maria’s nerves. She didn’t always ramble this much, surely? It really had been ages since she’d spoken to anyone.
Harris fidgeted in his seat. “Maria,” he began. “Are you…alright?”
The body blinked. “Hm?”
“You seem like you’re working through some things.”
“All is perfectly well.” Her body’s smile was glassy. “Don’t worry.”
“Are you sure?” Harris’s voice carried an edge. “What you’ve said sounds intense. Death in the family is a lot to handle. Not to mention the dieting stuff…have you talked to anyone about it?”
“I don’t know what you mean. Everything’s fine.”
You’re not fine, Maria almost screamed. Anyone with a brain could tell. And then she stopped herself, because it was her body, after all. It mirrored her exactly.
After breakfast, Maria’s body invited Harris over to see her vinyl collection. Maria didn’t own any vinyls, but Harris had mentioned buying a record player, and the body looked hopelessly lovestruck.
Maria kept her distance from the bedroom, trying to avoid any passionate noises that might escape. She floated past the possessions identifying the apartment as hers: the beat-up sneakers by the door, sweatpants draped over the couch, old photographs lining the wall. All objects meant to be worn, or perceived in.
Maria hated how she looked in the photos, but she’d figured they were what others expected to see. There were the optimistic photos from her housewarming party. The pictures from her doomed trip to France with Kevin, only half were missing because she’d removed the ones with painful memories. And, of course, the dance shots. A younger Maria leapt onstage, head thrown back, legs spread wide in a grande jeté. She could still hear her mother barking orders. Shoulders down! Keep those lines extended.
Maria shuddered. Her body, now independent, had her memories and even its own aggravating personality. What did she have, then?
The bits left over. Whatever that meant.
The bedroom door burst open. Harris stumbled through, his face bright red.
A sense of doom descended upon Maria.
“I’m sorry!” the body stammered, its hair disheveled. “I thought…the moment seemed right—”
“I thought we were just hanging out,” Harris blurted. “I never thought about you like that. You, and—and me…” He shook his head. “I need to go.”
He fled, leaving Maria alone with herself.
The body stared after him. Maria hovered nearby. She couldn’t help feeling somewhat smug.
“Not so easy calling the shots, huh?”
“Shut up,” her body snarled. It stormed to the bedroom and changed into pajamas, tossing the sundress into the trash.
“Serves you right.”
The body ignored her, digging through the closet with renewed vigor. More clothing went into the garbage: Maria’s swimsuit, a ragged pair of skinny jeans. The body unearthed the lingerie set that Kevin had bought for her birthday, and Maria’s invisible cheeks burned. She’d never had the right figure for it. The body’s face darkened in anger, and it ripped the lacy brassiere in half with one twist.
It went back into the closet. A soft clunk echoed out. The body had found a dusty wooden box, the gilt edges tarnished from age. Maria froze at the sight.
She remembered driving the five hours back from their faded brick house for the last time. A white picket fence. The box rattling in the passenger seat, carrying the last of Maria’s old existence.
“Hey,” she said. “What are you doing with Mom’s old stuff?”
Trembling, the body opened the box. There were more dance photographs. One depicted a pudgy three-year-old squeezed into a tutu. Another had a dark-haired teenager scowling onstage. Her body rummaged, growing hastier. It pulled out a wrinkled leotard, and dried-out petals from some ancient show bouquet fluttered out.
The body wrinkled its nose. Maria couldn’t smell anymore, but she could still imagine what staleness fermented inside that box. Workouts in sweaty rooms, the nauseating taste of ground spinach on an empty stomach, perfume and hairspray collecting backstage. Her mother’s breath, hovering as she pulled flyaway strands from Maria’s braids.
When Maria did poorly, she alone felt her mother’s icy disappointment. But when she did well, her mother glowed. Everyone at the post-show reception came to know Mrs. Naismith and her beautiful, talented daughter.
The backstage sat empty now. But Maria remained.
Her body pulled out the last piece of dance memorabilia, breathing heavily.
Nothing else remained of her mother’s treasures.
“What’s going to happen to me?” Maria asked.
The body looked up, startled. A frightened expression crossed its face, which it hid.
“You’ll fade away.”
She stiffened. “Into nothing?”
“Obviously. Well, probably.” The body slammed the box shut. “Who cares?
You’re always clinging onto the past, Maria. Learn to let go.”
Tears glistened on its cheeks. A bitter feeling rose in Maria’s throat.
“You’re angry,” she said.
The body didn’t respond.
“Why are you so angry with me?” She raised her voice. “I was just trying my best, wasn’t I?”
Its eyes glinted like knives. “It’s none of your business anymore.”
“I’ve got problems too! Why blame me? Why is everything my fault?”
“Because you threw us to the wolves!” the body cried. “To her. How could you let anyone do that to yourself?”
The box clattered to the ground. Piercing silence filled the air.
“So that’s what this is about,” she said.
The body’s hands shook. Maria wondered how absurd they looked, a woman arguing with herself. But the body slumped against the wall, defeated.
“I hated her,” it said, so bluntly that Maria almost smiled.
“Me too.”
“But I still miss her.”
“Me too.”
“She hated me too.” The body wept now, its words ragged gasps. “She was never satisfied. Too bloated, too clumsy, unsightly. We starved ourselves and practiced until our knees gave out. You never walked right again after that broken ankle. But now she’s gone.”
Maria studied its puffy eyes. It looked smaller now, younger. For the first time, she wondered what it felt like to have a sister.
“We still have each other,” she said.
“No,” the body spat. “You were part of it. I saw it every time you looked in the mirror. You compared me to the other girls and hated me just for existing.”
Maria stammered, taken aback. “That’s not true.”
Was it?
“Don’t lie to me, don’t…” The body doubled over. “Ugh. I feel horrible. Like I’m suffocating, but the walls are closing in on me. My stomach burns.”
She examined the body again, every blemish, wrinkle, and ounce of fat. The body’s face was too dull, its complexion unflattering. She’d always hated her appearance when she cried. A soggy mess seeped from the body’s flushed face. She knew what it was feeling—vision blurred from tears, nose rubbed raw, eyelids swollen for hours afterward. She’d always been like this; once Maria started crying, she couldn’t stop. The body scrubbed desperately at its wet face, trying to stem the flow.
No. Nobody else in the world would ever understand her better.
“You haven’t eaten all day,” Maria said. “I know you’re hungry. Eat something.”
Her body blinked, surprised. “I ate breakfast. Twice.”
“Smoothies aren’t real food. There’s some leftover pizza in the fridge you haven’t thrown out yet.”
“Pizza?” The body grimaced. “I shouldn’t…”
“Who cares if it’s not healthy? It’s fine, just this once.”
Maria gestured towards the kitchen, and the body shuffled in. It microwaved two pizza slices and sat on the couch to eat. The body chewed hesitantly.
“Tastes good. I guess we were hungry.”
She couldn’t help smiling. “Remember when we used to be lactose intolerant?”
“That was ages ago.” Its eyes were dry now. “When we had Coach Amy, right? She forgot and bought us a cheeseburger at a recital. We were on the toilet for an hour.”
“Oh yeah. Mom almost keeled over after she found out.”
“Right, and we finally got out ten minutes before the show started. Mom did our show hair so fast she stabbed us with a bobby pin. We performed with blood on our tights.”
Maria stared at it. “You remember that? I don’t even remember that.”
The body gave her a small smile.
“I remember everything you do, Maria. I’ve kept records.” It showed her a faint scar on its neck. “Ever since you were born.”
They stayed on the couch, talking. The body showed Maria another scar on its knee from when she’d fallen headfirst down a slide when she was eight. They reminisced about the time she’d gotten drunk in college and climbed the clock tower overlooking campus. The body’s sense of humor was rather good. It made a pointed remark about Kevin’s lacking personal hygiene, and as they chuckled, Maria heard her own laugh from the outside for the first time.
“It’s funny,” she murmured. “Hearing about myself from your perspective. Like someone watched over my shoulder all this time.”
The body shrugged. “I’ve always been here. It’s my life too, after all.”
“Yeah. I’m starting to understand that.” Maria felt a swell of guilt. “Sorry about the broken ankle. We only get two of those in the long run.”
“Ah, well.” It yawned. “What good is a body for, if not to live life with?”
The hours passed into late afternoon, and the body grew silent. When Maria looked over, it was asleep, pajama-clad chest rising and falling. They’d had a long day. Even she, with no physical sensations to judge by, could feel the mental weight dragging her down.
Maria reoriented herself, giving the body more space. It snored, and she wondered what flesh dreamt of when there was no mind to animate it.
For once, the apartment didn’t feel quite so empty.
She closed her eyes and drifted off.
When Maria awoke, she was alone. The couch creaked under her weight, and her skin prickled in the chill evening air. Astonished, she touched her face, and her cheeks were dotted with happy tears.