The sea was calm as I pushed up from the depths, toward the orange glow of sunset. I surfaced and paddled my way to the shore, letting the waves carry me. My belly rippled along the sand as I pushed toward the rocky cliff where I’d stashed my clothes.
Often the shore was empty. But on this particular night, a flock of people danced and laughed around a large fire, drinking beer and roasting marshmallows as sparks rose into the darkness.
I hid behind a jagged boulder, stripped off my sealskin and stood, feeling along the rock face until I found the loose stone and pulled it free. Behind it were a pair of worn jeans, a flannel shirt and black boots. I dressed quickly and stuffed my pelt into the hole.
The last of the sunlight danced gold on the surface of the ocean as the sky turned purple and pink. I let out a long breath of air and wrapped my arms around myself, grateful to be on land after months away. There was something about it that made me feel more solid.
I slipped among the partygoers like I was returning from a walk along the beach. There were enough of them that anyone would have thought I was there with someone else.
My kind came ashore from time to time, each for their own reasons, I suppose. For me, it was a chance to imagine what human life was like. My elders often warned me about them, about what they did to us. But I loved their faces, their laughter, how carefree they seemed.
As I scanned the crowd, one of them caught my eye. He was across the fire from me, sitting on a driftwood log, watching the flames. Even seated, I could tell he was tall, slender as sea grass, with milky skin, full lips and long, white-gold curls tumbling down his back. A cigarette rested, smoldering, between his fingers. My mind echoed with my ancestors’ stories, especially the ones about elves of the earth and the woods. Their long, pale hair.
Before I knew what I was doing, my legs carried me around the fire, where I sat down on the log next to him. His eyes remained fixed on the flames; he didn’t seem to see me.
“Reading your fortune?” I asked, clearing the last of the sea from my throat.
“Hm?” He shook his head and blinked, as though coming out of a trance. His mouth curled up at one corner. “Something like that.”
“What did you see?” I asked.
He adopted a mock-dramatic tone. “A great darkness on the horizon. Forces gather like leaves in a windstorm. Or maybe I’m just really tired.” He lifted a cigarette to his lips, sucked in the smoke and held it. When he exhaled, I smelled burning herbs—cannabis, mint maybe.
“Do you know these people?” I asked, gesturing toward the scattered partygoers. The air radiating off the fire crackled my skin, a sharp shift from the cold salt sea.
“Some,” he said, taking another drag. With the cigarette held between two fingers, he pointed the lit end toward a pair of boys to his right, who were talking to a soft-bodied blonde. “I know those two. Not the girl. You?”
“Not really,” I shrugged. “I saw the fire, thought I’d come see what’s going on.”
“Do you live around here?”
“Yeah, not too far,” I said, not entirely a lie. My clan spent most of its time on a small, rocky island about a half-mile off the coast. We hunted the surrounding waters for salmon, rockfish and sweet crabs. “What about you?”
“I live just a couple miles inland, in the woods,” he said, putting the cigarette to his full lips and breathing in slowly. He offered it to me. “You want some?”
I shook my head and looked out across the darkening horizon. He elbowed me in the side, cracking a smile. “Follow me. See if you can keep up,” he said, dashing toward the water while I trailed behind. Running in soft sand is hard enough, let alone when you haven’t had legs in a while. But the movement, the night air, made my body tingle.
He pulled off his boots and socks, then scraped the sand with his toes. As he did, little blue twinkles appeared. “Bioluminescent critters,” he said. I followed his lead, feeling the rasp of wet sand under my toe. A larger wave washed ashore, soaking us to our calves.
“Oooh, that’s cold,” he said as the wave pulled away, burying our feet in new sand.
“I like it,” I said.
He stepped closer and tentatively took my hand in his, both of us looking out to sea. As I squeezed his hand back, warmth throbbed down my body. He pulled away, replacing my warmth with doubt.
“Shit, too many beers,” he said. “I’ve gotta pee. Will you be here when I get back?”
I nodded, stomach knotted, wondering if he was making an excuse to get away from something that was happening too swiftly. He jogged toward the cliffs, disappeared into darkness. Meanwhile I counted the waves, reassured to see that every seventh swell was bigger than the others. Their white caps glowed in the moonlight. Some things stayed true, no matter what.
A few minutes later I heard footsteps behind me. When I turned, his face was shadowed, white-gold hair side-lit by the bonfire. He held something in his arms. Something leathery and damp. Ice spiked my veins.
Humans see our kind more often than they realize. We are indistinguishable from seals that can’t change their skins, and we often live among our sea cousins, keeping each other safe from bigger predators, humans included. Ashore, we look just like people. Warm skin, ten fingers and ten toes, nothing to give us away but our pelts. They could trap us this way, humans.
“I found this in the rocks.” His voice trembled. He stood inches away from me now, my brown sealskin clutched to his chest like a newborn. “Just looked up, and there it was.” His blue eyes fixed on mine. “Is it yours?” He asked.
I took a step back, waves lapping the thick rubber of my bootsoles, tried to think of what to do. If I denied it, he might take it and I’d be bound to him. Maybe I could knock him down and grab it, disappear before he realized what had happened. I was strong enough.
But I couldn’t stop thinking of the way he’d touched my hand just a few minutes earlier, the way it made me ache.
Raising my hands, I started to open my mouth, though I didn’t know what might come out.
“I know what you are,” he said softly. “I’ve read all the old stories: Mer-folk, merrows, selkies. I never thought I’d find one.”
I thought I’d hidden it well enough. No one had ever—
“Come home with me,” he said.
I swallowed hard. “If you know what I am, then you know why I won’t.”
He looked down at the bundle in his arms for a moment, clarity reshaping his features. “Oh, no, no,” he said, handing me my skin. “That’s not what this is.”
It was heavy, still damp from the sea. As he laid it in my arms, he leaned down, face inches from mine, smoke clinging to his sweet breath.
I closed the gap between us and pressed my lips to his, opening to his tongue, the earthy taste of him. He moaned into my mouth and pressed his chest against mine. Heat flooded my body.
“Let’s go,” I whispered against his lips, my head spinning.
He took my hand and led me past the bonfire, up to the parking lot where a dingy white pickup waited. As he drove, I rolled my window down, letting the cold wind stroke my face. A canopy of redwoods swallowed the stars, a velvet shield between us and the world. He guided the truck across a narrow wooden bridge and parked in front of a two-story, blood-red house, almost black in the darkness.
In his cluttered room we peeled each other’s clothes away hungrily, a tangle of limbs and jeans and buttons until we were naked in the moonlight streaming through his window. I fell against him onto the bed shoved against one wall, kissed him up and down his lanky body, took him into my mouth until he moaned and pulled me up to kiss him. When he slid inside me, everything else disappeared except for the places where my body connected to his.
I woke in a knot of sheets to the sight of him sitting next to the bed in a battered armchair, strumming a guitar. He hummed something I didn’t recognize, his voice deep and sure. I reached out and ran my hand down one long thigh as he lifted his storm-blue eyes to mine.
“Hey,” I said, my voice still thick with sleep.
He put the guitar aside and stretched out next to me, pressing the length of his body to mine. I held the back of his head and pulled him into a kiss, rolled him on top of me. His weight on me felt like diving deep under the waves, a pressure solid and soothing.
“Mmmm,” he said, stroking between my legs. “Was last night your first time with a human?”
“Last night was my first time with anyone,” I said.
“Oh, shit, really? If I’d known, I would have been more gentle.”
“No.” I groaned, sinking into a place almost beyond words. “I really liked it. I loved it.”
He paused, then sat back, resting against the wall, studying me. “Why me?”
I shrugged. “I didn’t really plan any of this.”
“But,” he paused, considering his words. “Why not with someone… more like you?”
I sat up, too, and pulled the blankets up to my waist, feeling too exposed. “Sure, that’s what my clan expects me to do.” I shook my head. “But I have a hard time doing what’s expected of me. My podmates are always on me to stay in the sea, find a mate, make sure we’re looking out for each other. And I want that. I do. But I often find myself thinking of your world. Wondering.”
He pushed himself across the bed and wrapped me in his arms, hot against my cooling skin. When he pressed his stubbled cheek to mine, his face was wet with tears.
We made love again, then moved to the bright, plant-filled kitchen, where we stuffed ourselves and said good morning to his younger sister, still a girl.
“Where are your parents?” I asked, popping a grape into my mouth. “They go away for a few days, or something?”
He went silent for so long, I wondered if he would ever answer. “My dad took off years ago. My mom died last year. Cancer. She left us the house.”
“I’m so sorry.”
He shrugged. As he looked past me and out the kitchen window, deep pain flashed in his eyes.
“I’m an orphan, too,” I said quietly. “Both my parents died when I was younger. A red algae bloom poisoned our waters. The rest of our pod took care of me afterward.”
“Last night, you said something about reading stories about—about people like me,” I said, touching his arm. “What did you mean?”
“Growing up here, so close to the ocean, my mom read us a lot of stories about mermaids and sirens, stuff like that. She took us to the Marine Mammal Center and the Monterey Bay Aquarium so we could learn about everything that lives right off the shore, real and imagined,” he said. “When she died, I started collecting and reading books on sea mythology. It helped me feel like she was still with me.”
He stood. “Follow me.”
We moved into the front room, where a wooden trunk stood against one wall, worn with time but elaborately carved. “Your skin is in here.” He lifted the lid to reveal my brown, speckled pelt. “Anytime you need it, this is where you’ll find it. Whether that’s right now, tomorrow, or someday.”
I hadn’t even realized I’d lost track of it. My family tree is full of lost ancestors, skins stolen by humans hungry for something ineffable. A knot loosened in my gut as he closed the lid and I saw there wasn’t even a way to lock it.
“Come on,” he said, tugging on my hand. “I want to show you the woods.”
His house was surrounded by a grove of redwoods, clinging to the last tendrils of morning fog. The air cooled as we walked deeper into the trees, but his hand in mine was warm.
“Are you supposed to be at work, or school, or something?” I asked.
He smiled. “Well, it’s Sunday, so, no. But I just finished community college, and I’m taking the summer off before I figure out what’s next.”
“What did you study?”
“Mostly general stuff, in case I want to go to a university,” he said. “But I also wrote a lot—short stories, articles for the college newspaper. I liked it.”
We came to the banks of a creek with no more than a trickle of water in the bottom. “In the winter and spring, it rains so much that the water comes up to the bridge.” He pointed to the wooden structure. “The people who live in this area say that anything supernatural can’t cross the water.”
“I’m pretty sure that’s not true,” I laughed.
We walked back into the trees and followed a path that led to a small, sunny clearing. Turkey vultures circled lazily overhead as he sat down in the drying grass and patted the space beside him. Amber poppies nodded in the breeze, and the wind in the eucalyptus leaves overhead sounded like waves brushing the shore.
“When you read all those stories, did you ever think any of it was real?” I asked, tracing my fingers across his cheek.
“No. But I hoped it was.” He smiled. “Is it true? That your kind cast spells on humans to make us lovesick and devoted?”
“You’ll have to tell me.”
He squinted into the sky, but didn’t answer. I leaned my head against his shoulder, realizing that, for the first time in a long time, I didn’t have to hide anything.
We spent a week together in the red house, talking, listening to music, reading, cooking, and joining our bodies in every way we could. I’d never felt so at home on land, had never met someone who felt so familiar. I’d never felt so weightless.
But I needed to go home, if only to let my family know I was safe. I lifted my pelt from the trunk and held it in my lap as he drove me to the shore. Blackened driftwood from our bonfire was strewn across the beach, as though tossed by a giant. He walked me to the boulder where I usually hid my clothes and gently undressed me, tucking everything into the hole behind the loose stone. I pressed my lips to his, sucking his tongue into my mouth, shivering naked in the dawn wind.
“I won’t be gone long,” I said, stepping into the waves.
“You’d better not,” he smiled. “I won’t know what to do with myself.”
“How will you know when I’m back?”
“I have a feeling I’ll just know,” he said, brushing my hand with his. “Still, I’ll check back every day at sundown.”
I turned and dove under, slipping my skin on as I swam. When I reached our rocky island, my podmates barked in greeting, but something was wrong.
A cluster of seals had formed a circle at the peak of the island, and I moved closer to see what they were doing. In the center was our matriarch, barely moving and paler than I’d ever seen her.
I moved closer, touched her nose with my own, breathed into her as if somehow I could bring her back. She moaned so softly, only I could hear. Foam seeped from her mouth.
My heart fell. After my parents died, she’d raised me herself, though she was old enough to be my great-grandmother. She taught me to dive and hunt with a skill I’d never witnessed in another of our kind, and she was always the first to make sure the rest of us were fed and safe.
I could hear her now, scolding me for escaping again and again to the surface, for longing to know what humans were like, what they did all day. “Remember, child,” she would say, tossing still-wriggling fish to the youngest ones with a flick of her head. “Just because you can pass as human, doesn’t mean you’ll ever be one.”
If not for her, I might have pretended my way into the human world years ago. If not for her, that night I got caught in a fishing net, I might have been hauled onto some boat and severed from my skin for good. I’d forever be grateful that she followed me, tore the net apart with her strong teeth, and swore at me all the way home.
It was impossible that she lay here now, fading against the stones so solid beneath her. I stayed by her side until her breath left her, and it felt like mine would leave me, too.
We stayed with her body for days, none of us hunting, eating, or sleeping. Together we sang over her, keening as the sun rose over the golden hills and set in the ocean, calling to the waters to take her home. And then we rolled her body to the edge and into the sea, where she sank with barely a ripple.
I stayed one more day, hunting and eating my fill of rockfish and cod. To honor her, I brought back plenty to feed the pod before setting out toward the shore again. Love and grief danced strange circles around my heart as I swam.
He was sitting on the beach when I emerged from the water, his feet bare in the wet sand, shivering in his leather jacket. I shed my pelt and kneeled before him, took his face into my hands. Tears streamed down his cheeks.
“I thought you were gone,” he whispered.
“I’m so, so sorry.” I kissed his eyes closed and held him to my chest. “I couldn’t get away. I lost someone very close to me, and I needed to say goodbye. But I’m here now. Will you please take me home?”
I’d only been away a week, but when we undressed each other in the candlelight, I saw how much he’d changed. His already-slender frame looked skeletal, and dark shadows hung beneath his eyes. I touched his ribs and asked, “Are you okay?”
“It’s nothing,” he shrugged. “I was sick for a couple of days.”
We lay down beside each other on the bed, face to face, chest to chest, toes to toes. I ran one fingertip along his eyebrows, down his nose, across his lips, where he sucked my finger into his mouth. We made love, slept, made love, slept, devouring each other and slipping into dreams until dawn turned the sky pink.
When I woke, the sun was high and I was alone. I pulled on my clothes and walked from room to room, but the house was empty, echoing with my footsteps. Finally I found him sitting on the porch, holding my sealskin in his lap.
I sat beside him and leaned in for a kiss, but he pulled back. “Don’t.”
My limbs went cold. “What’s going on?”
He shuddered and his hands squeezed my pelt, frightened. “I lied. I wasn’t sick for a couple days. I was sick the whole time you were gone. I couldn’t eat, I couldn’t sleep, I couldn’t do anything but miss you. I felt like I was out of my mind.”
“I’m really sorry—”
“It isn’t your fault.” He wouldn’t look at me, eyes veiled by white-gold curls. His voice turned acid. “I mean, you can’t help it. It’s your magic, or whatever you want to call it. When we’re together, I feel amazing. Like I could do anything, or like I could disappear with you and never miss the rest of the world. And when you’re gone, I’m strung out. I would destroy everything to get back to you.”
“What is this?” I whispered.
He shoved the sealskin into my lap, but I could only let it slip to the earth.
I stood to face him, a sob stuck in my throat. “What about your magic? Your gingerbread house in your enchanted forest, your golden hair and your fucking white horse,” I gestured to the muddy truck behind me. “What we have is once in a lifetime. Maybe once in a thousand lifetimes.” My throat stung with anger.
“Just because it’s rare doesn’t mean it’s good for us,” he said, rising to his feet. “I was so, so excited when I found out what you were. But I didn’t know what it would do to me. I just didn’t.”
He searched the trees, as if they held some answer. “One of us needs to end this before it swallows us both alive,” he said.
“Then what was last night?”
“One last time.”
He opened the passenger door of his truck, then got in on the driver’s side and waited.
“Fuck you!” I shouted, storming across the bridge and onto the dirt lane that led away from the house.
I don’t know how long I walked, head throbbing, eyes blurry with tears. Until the dirt lane joined the paved road, and then along the pavement until I reached the highway. My feet ached and bled, but I barely noticed. It wasn’t until he pulled up beside me in the truck that I let myself feel how exhausted I was.
Silently I got in, and he drove to the shore. Our shore. The beach was empty, a rare summer storm scattering fat raindrops onto the sand. Seals called out in the waves, but they weren’t the voices of my kin.
“At least look at me,” I said, and he brushed the hair back from his face. His eyes were stormy, rimmed in red. I wanted to reach out, bury my face in his warm neck, breathe in his scent of leather and dark woods. But I kept my hands wrapped around my pelt as he looked toward the waves, tears spilling from his eyes.
“Nobody will ever love you the way I love you,” I said, turning to walk into the water.
“I know,” I heard him say, somewhere behind me, before the pounding of the waves swallowed his words.